Question

Lately we have suddenly been seeing a few of the following stack traces. Why could that be? This is from when the app tries to move an audio commentary service into the foreground with a media notification and everything.

java.lang.SecurityException: Permission Denial: startForeground from pid=1824, uid=10479 requires android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE
    at android.os.Parcel.createException(Parcel.java:1942)
    at android.os.Parcel.readException(Parcel.java:1910)
    at android.os.Parcel.readException(Parcel.java:1860)
    at android.app.IActivityManager$Stub$Proxy.setServiceForeground(IActivityManager.java:5198)
    at android.app.Service.startForeground(Service.java:695)
    at com.example.app.services.AudioService.setUpMediaNotification(AudioService.java:372)
    at com.example.app.services.AudioService.setUpAndStartAudioFeed(AudioService.java:328)
    at com.example.app.services.AudioService.onStartCommand(AudioService.java:228)
    at android.app.ActivityThread.handleServiceArgs(ActivityThread.java:3667)
    at android.app.ActivityThread.access$1600(ActivityThread.java:199)
    at android.app.ActivityThread$H.handleMessage(ActivityThread.java:1681)
    at android.os.Handler.dispatchMessage(Handler.java:106)
    at android.os.Looper.loop(Looper.java:193)
    at android.app.ActivityThread.main(ActivityThread.java:6669)
    at java.lang.reflect.Method.invoke(Native Method)
    at com.android.internal.os.RuntimeInit$MethodAndArgsCaller.run(RuntimeInit.java:493)
    at com.android.internal.os.ZygoteInit.main(ZygoteInit.java:858)
 Caused by: android.os.RemoteException: Remote stack trace:
    at com.android.server.am.ActivityManagerService.enforcePermission(ActivityManagerService.java:9186)
    at com.android.server.am.ActiveServices.setServiceForegroundInnerLocked(ActiveServices.java:1189)
    at com.android.server.am.ActiveServices.setServiceForegroundLocked(ActiveServices.java:870)
    at com.android.server.am.ActivityManagerService.setServiceForeground(ActivityManagerService.java:20434)
    at android.app.IActivityManager$Stub.onTransact(IActivityManager.java:976)

Roy Solberg · Accepted Answer · 2018-12-19 08:19:07Z

This is what you get for not reading the release notes properly. This started happening when setting targetSdkVersion = 28 (Android 9 / Pie) and is clearly stated in e.g. the migration notes:

Apps wanting to use foreground services must now request the FOREGROUND_SERVICE permission first. This is a normal permission, so the system automatically grants it to the requesting app. Starting a foreground service without the permission throws a SecurityException.

So the solution is to just add the following in AndroidManifest.xml:

<manifest ...>
     ...
     <uses-permission android:name="android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE" />
     ...
     <application ...>
     ...
</manifest>

Does that mean if our targetSdkVersion is lower than 28, we don't need any permission to run the Foreground services in devices running 28? — Volleyball, Sep 27 '18 at 7:39
That sounds like a weird solution to me, to lower the targetSdkVersion — Denny, Nov 18 '18 at 15:17
@Volleyball your app won't install on devices running 28 if your targetSdkVersion is lower than 28 — Sjd, Feb 19 at 13:34
@Sjd They will install just fine. It's not like it's maxSdkVersion. — Roy Solberg, Feb 19 at 14:45

score 18 · Answer 2

Permission Denial: startForeground requires android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE

Apps that target Android 9 (API level 28) or higher and use foreground services must request the FOREGROUND_SERVICE permission.

So now we need to add Foreground service permission in manifest file

it Allows a regular application to use Service.startForeground

SAMPLE

<uses-permission android:name="android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE" />

FOREGROUND_SERVICE is a normal permission, so the system automatically grants it to the requesting app.

Check this the migration notes of Android 9 / Pie

Change

Foreground service permission

Summary

Apps wanting to use foreground services must now request the FOREGROUND_SERVICE permission first. This is a normal permission, so the system automatically grants it to the requesting app. Starting a foreground service without the permission throws a SecurityException.

번호	제목	글쓴이	조회 수	날짜
96	안드로이드 스튜디오 PreferenceActivity로 설정창 쉽게 만들기	admin	9858	2020-01-17
96
95	안드로이드 원그래프 걱은선그래프 만들기 그리기	admin	8392	2019-12-24
95
94	[Android] activity 인텐트(Intent) 화면 간 이동과 데이터 전달 잘된설명	admin	8665	2019-12-24
94
93	안드로이드 웹뷰 webview 설명좀 잘해놓은곳 androidx 사용	admin	8384	2019-12-24
93
92	안드로이드 비동기 통신 결과값을 Textview set text 값 설정 기록 표시셋 이해 하기 쉽게	admin	8170	2019-12-17
92
91	안드로이드 6.0 permission 가장잘된 예제	admin	8025	2019-12-12
91
90	How to fish notification enable	admin	8105	2019-10-13
90
89	FCM 푸시 메세지 전송	admin	8286	2019-09-27
89
88	안드로이드 디버깅 Logcat을 이용해서 로그 남기기	admin	9099	2019-09-18
88
87	FCM 원하는 액티비티 이름을 알림을 요청 전송하여 액티비티 열리게	admin	11222	2019-06-24
87
86	FirebaseInstanceIdService is deprecated now FCM token	admin	9704	2019-05-29
86
	android 9 startForeground requires android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE	admin	10463	2019-05-25
	https://stackoverflow.com/questions/52382710/permission-denial-startforeground-requires-android-permission-foreground-servic Ask Question 87 15 Lately we have suddenly been seeing a few of the following stack traces. Wh...
84	Android OS 9 Pie 동작 변경사항 정리 개발자용	admin	9597	2019-05-25
84
83	Google wants developers to add dark themes to save battery life	admin	8975	2019-03-28
83
82	Notification에 관한 설명 자세한설명	admin	10253	2019-03-01
82
81	android.telephony.TelephonyManager.getSubscriberId 베스트코드 code	admin	9854	2018-12-31
81
80	안드로이드 getDeviceId getImei MEID	admin	10634	2018-12-28
80
79	안드로이드 백 뒤로가기 버튼 back button of action bar in Android	admin	18519	2018-12-24
79
78	In favour of overriding onNewToken FirebaseMessagingService	admin	12492	2018-12-22
78
77	Android Service and Jobscheduler sourcecode	admin	9088	2018-12-22
77
76	안드로이드 OREO 백그라운드 서비스 제한 대책	admin	12463	2018-12-22
76
75	JobScheduler - Android Studio Tutorial	admin	9988	2018-12-22
75
74	Android 9 Pie 새로운기능	admin	10606	2018-12-22
74
73	동작 변경사항: API 레벨 28+를 대상으로 하는 앱 Android Pie	admin	12197	2018-12-22
73
72	jobscheduler 간략하게 설명	admin	10178	2018-12-22
72
71	Android-Oreo-Foreground-Service-Simple-Example 쉽고 정확한설명	admin	10820	2018-12-22
71
70	Oreo 버전 이후 Foreground Service 사용 방법	admin	14101	2018-12-22
70
69	Android sms intent filter SMS 보내기	admin	9542	2018-12-19
69
68	add set and cancel of the notification on those listeners	admin	9106	2018-12-14
68
67	android.os.Build.VERSION_CODES.O 오레오 알림 작성 소스코드	admin	9323	2018-12-14
67
66	android.os.Build.VERSION_CODES.O 오레오 알림 작성	admin	10032	2018-12-14
66
65	Android Oreo의 알림 채널	admin	10603	2018-12-10
65
64	System Permission MODIFY_PHONE_STATE root device	admin	11131	2018-12-08
64
63	일반 Activity와 AppCompatActivity의 차이 ?	admin	9570	2018-12-06
63
62	런타임 안드로이드 권한 SDK 23 이상 권한 부여하기 코드	admin	9561	2018-12-06
62
61	안드로이드 마시맬로 6.0 이상의 런타임 권한	admin	10711	2018-12-05
61
60	Runtime Permissions in Android Marshmallow 6.0 and above	admin	15932	2018-12-05
60
59	Android 6.0(API 레벨 23)부터 사용자 런타임에 권한 요청	admin	10627	2018-12-05
59
58	firebase로 손쉽게 android 앱에 로그인 추가하기	admin	11010	2018-12-05
58
57	android apk 패키징 v1, v2	admin	10128	2018-12-05
57
56	Android Shape Drawable Examples	admin	9854	2018-12-05
56
55	Android Drawable Resources Tutorial	admin	11354	2018-12-05
55
54	새로운 안드로이드 백그라운드 작업 처리법 : WorkManager	admin	13115	2018-11-25
54
53	안드로이드 : 컨텐트 제공자 (Content Provider) 연락처 데이터 ContentResolver 객체	admin	10843	2018-11-21
53
52	Android Contact APP with RecyclerView Part 1: Call Logs Example Android Studio	admin	10724	2018-11-18
52
51	SMS 또는 통화 기록 사용 위험도 가 높거나 민감한 권한을 사용하는 것을 제한	admin	12833	2018-11-18
51
50	안드로이드 스튜디오 에서 팩키지명 변경하기 동영상 으로 보기	admin	9312	2018-10-01
50
49	안드로이드 개발시에 팩키지명 변경하기	admin	9393	2018-09-21
49
48	안드로이드 전화 수신 발신 이력조회 CALLLOG	admin	10220	2018-09-10
48
47	Android 6.0 이상 접근권한 checkselfPermission source code	admin	9802	2018-09-06
47
46	안드로이드 마쉬멜로우 버전 이상에서 권한처리하기.	admin	10352	2018-09-06
46
45	안드로이드 버전 역사	admin	9717	2018-09-01
45
44	안드로이드 사용자 주소록리스트 가져오기	admin	11074	2018-06-16
44
43	@Deprecated @Override 라는 어노테이션 사용 설명	admin	12802	2018-06-16
43
42	get path dir 함수 종합 정리	admin	10487	2018-05-25
42
41	unpublish an app in Google Play Developer Console 플레이스토어 앱 게시 삭제	admin	11159	2018-05-21
41
40	how to set CheckBoxPreference default value 체크박스 디폴트값 설정	admin	11446	2018-05-16
40
39	SDK Platform Release Notes	admin	10013	2018-05-13
39
38	sdk-tools list	admin	10915	2018-05-13
38
37	P is for Policy: Upcoming changes to Google Play	admin	10241	2018-05-13
37
36	Improving app security and performance on Google Play for years to come	admin	10299	2018-05-13
36
35	Play Store to require new and updated apps to target recent API levels and distribute native apps with 64-bit support	admin	10349	2018-05-13
35
34	8.0 부터는 Notification Channel을 만들어 주기 하지 않으면 알림이 오지 않는다	admin	16401	2018-05-11
34
33	Notification 을 사용 알림 지워지지 않고 여러개 표시 되게 하는 방법	admin	12442	2018-05-11
33
32	Gradle Wrapper를 통해 이용하기	admin	10415	2018-05-07
32
31	goodbye to your implicit BroadcastReceivers	admin	9793	2018-05-01
31
30	Questions & Answers Android 개발자	admin	9856	2018-04-26
30
29	Firebase용 Cloud 함수	admin	10919	2018-04-26
29
28	Firebase FCM 강제로 onTokenRefresh () 호출 [android] 서버로 json put token 전송	admin	11490	2018-04-26
28
27	How to initialize default preferences for Settings in Android 초기값 설정	admin	10438	2018-04-25
27
26	설정값 유지하기 ( SharedPreferences ) 쉽고 잘된설명	admin	14678	2018-03-22
26
25	안드로이드 알람	admin	10405	2018-02-23
25
24	Uri to default sound notification?	admin	10267	2018-02-03
24
23	[안드로이드 개발자 개발 ] 기본 스레드의 생명주기 관리 자세히 알아보기	admin	11435	2018-01-16
23
22	안드로이드 개발자 개발 프로그램 7.0 누가 백그라운드 최적화	admin	11830	2018-01-16
22
21	안드로이드 android MediaPlayer how to work	admin	10253	2018-01-16
21
20	gcm 코딩 사례	admin	10248	2018-01-09
20
19	Doze 및 앱 대기 모드 최적화 GCM으로 Android M Doze 모드를 풀기	admin	11358	2018-01-09
19
18	Service와 BroadcastReceiver로 스크린 화면 감지하기	admin	12957	2018-01-07
18
17	알림 애플리케이션의 정상 UI 외부에서 사용자에게 표시	admin	13037	2018-01-05
17
16	Firebase Console의 Notification google android 구글 안드로이드 푸시	admin	14830	2018-01-04
16
15	안드로이드 밧데리 전원 수명 오래쓰기 보안 최적화 끄기 끄는 방업 소개	admin	10230	2018-01-02
15
14	Android 7.0 동작 변경 사항 밧데리 메모리 잠자기 모드	admin	11820	2018-01-02
14
13	[Android] 배터리 최적화 대응하기: 도즈(Doze)와 어플 대기모드(App Standby)	admin	22739	2018-01-02
13
12	안드로이드 앱 배터리 최적화 무시방법	admin	14815	2018-01-02
12
11	How do I keep Wifi from disconnecting when phone is asleep?	admin	10243	2018-01-02
11
10	WIFI_SLEEP_POLICY_NEVER how to set in API-17?	admin	10569	2018-01-02
10
9	how do you import sound files like mp3 or waw files into android studio?	admin	10816	2018-01-02
9
8	Remote Notifications with Firebase Cloud Messaging	admin	11506	2018-01-02
8
7	안드로이드 버젼 별 특징 새로운 기능	admin	10433	2018-01-02
7
6	Doze 및 앱 대기 모드 최적화	admin	12778	2018-01-01
6
5	사용자는 Settings > Battery > Battery Optimization에서 수동으로 허용 과 프로그램	admin	10593	2018-01-01
5
4	FCM PHP Curld	admin	11219	2018-01-01
4
3	FCM 과 GCM 차이	admin	12627	2018-01-01
3
2	opensips Sipdroid Push notification how to	admin	10470	2017-12-27
2
1	Migrate a GCM Client App for Android to Firebase Cloud Messaging	admin	10955	2017-12-04
1

Coding

android 9 startForeground requires android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE

2 Answers

`FOREGROUND_SERVICE` is a normal permission, so the system automatically grants it to the requesting app.

Coding

android 9 startForeground requires android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE

2 Answers

FOREGROUND_SERVICE is a normal permission, so the system automatically grants it to the requesting app.

`FOREGROUND_SERVICE` is a normal permission, so the system automatically grants it to the requesting app.